(Madoka's had apple cider all of...once, maybe? She remembered liking it, so to concentrate that into pie form...the thought alone is getting her to smile.

The question does have her pondering the possibility. She's enjoys the little practices that give you good luck or grant a wish.)

Oh, like getting the larger part of a wishbone? Except that sounds a lot harder. I bet that one works more; it takes a lot of practice to peel an apple like that.

(She smiles brightly.) But that means you earned your wish, doesn't it? For working so hard to get it.